pwshub.com

Dave Ramsey Says You Should Withdraw At 8% In Retirement, But Suze Orman Says Absolutely Not And Calls Even 4% 'Very Dangerous' — Who's Right?

A debate over retirement withdrawal strategies has erupted, with financial experts Dave Ramsey and Suze Orman at the center. This topic was recently posted on the Power of Zero YouTube channel, where differing opinions have sparked a broader discussion among financial advisors and retirees.

Don't Miss:

The controversy began when a 30-year-old man with $120,000 saved for retirement called into "The Ramsey Show" seeking advice on how much of his assets he should withdraw annually over a 30-year retirement period. He mentioned a recent video by "The Ramsey Show" co-host George Kamel, which suggested a 3% withdrawal rate for those aiming to make their nest egg last.

Ramsey vehemently disagreed, saying, "I don't know what the hell George is doing with a 3% withdrawal rate because that's absolutely wrong. It's ridiculous." Ramsey recommended an 8% withdrawal rate instead, provided that retirees could earn a 12% annual return from "good mutual funds," aligning with the historical average annual return of the S&P 500. He argued that setting aside 4% for annual inflation made this approach feasible.

Ramsey's retirement advice quickly sparked backlash. Financial expert Rick Edelman responded, "Anyone following Ramsey's retirement withdrawal strategy is doomed." He added, "I and every other legitimate financial adviser have recommended to our clients that when you're in retirement and need to start withdrawing money from your investment, you should withdraw no more than 4% per year." The 4% rule has been a widely accepted standard for over 30 years.

Suze Orman also entered the fray, challenging the 8% and 4% rules with her conservative stance. In an interview with Moneywise, Orman stated, "It doesn't work anymore," adding, "I think it's very dangerous."

Trending: Rory McIlroy’s mansion in Florida is worth $22 million today, doubling from 2017 — here’s how to get started investing in real estate with just $100.

Orman has emphasized the need to preserve as much of the portfolio as possible for unexpected challenges, such as health issues. She recommends a 3% withdrawal rate, noting, "The less money you withdraw each year, the better off you are."

The implications of these differing strategies are significant, as pointed out in a YouTube video posted by the Power of Zero. For a 35-year-old planning to retire at 65 and live on $80,000 annually, Ramsey's 8% rule requires saving approximately $882 per year, assuming an 8% return. In contrast, Orman's 3% rule necessitates saving about $23,450 annually to meet the same retirement income goal.

This major difference underscores why Ramsey favors his higher withdrawal rate; it makes the savings goal seem more attainable.

Choosing the right withdrawal rate depends on individual circumstances and risk tolerance. While Ramsey's approach offers a more optimistic savings goal, Orman's conservative strategy aims to ensure long-term financial stability amidst unforeseen challenges.

Financial advisors continue to debate the merits of each approach, urging retirees to consider their unique needs and consult with professionals to make informed decisions.

Read Next:

"ACTIVE INVESTORS' SECRET WEAPON" Supercharge Your Stock Market Game with the #1 "news & everything else" trading tool: Benzinga Pro - Click here to start Your 14-Day Trial Now!

Get the latest stock analysis from Benzinga?

This article Dave Ramsey Says You Should Withdraw At 8% In Retirement, But Suze Orman Says Absolutely Not And Calls Even 4% 'Very Dangerous' — Who's Right? originally appeared on Benzinga.com

© 2024 Benzinga.com. Benzinga does not provide investment advice. All rights reserved.

Source: finance.yahoo.com

Related stories
2 weeks ago - Celebrated personal finance guru Dave Ramsey calls out Americans who consider saving enough money to quit their jobs because they hate them as a bad life plan. Here's what Ramsey had to say about this flawed approach. Don't Miss: The...
2 weeks ago - As retirement approaches, many couples face crucial decisions regarding their living arrangements. One such couple recently sought advice from financial expert Suze Orman on whether to buy a home or rent a luxury senior apartment. The...
2 weeks ago - During an episode of the Dave Ramsey Show, a concerned caller asked personal finance expert Dave Ramsey what to do after realizing her financial situation was not sustainable. Here's what Ramsey advised. Don't Miss: Are you rich? Here’s...
6 days ago - Renowned personal finance expert Suze Orman, host of the "Women & Money" podcast, recently shared several things that she firmly believes people should do if they receive an inheritance. "You have to look at your financial situation and...
1 week ago - An entire Florida homeowners association board quits after $60K special assessment dispute — what happenedHomeowners in the Villas of Carillon...
Other stories
6 minutes ago - Dow surges by more than 700 points as investors bet on September rate cut  CNNStock market today: Dow, S&P 500 build on records as a retail sales surprise fuels rate cut hopes  Yahoo FinanceUS stocks rise amid rate cut cheer; retail sales...
6 minutes ago - Nvidia’s market cap will soar to $50 trillion—yes, trillion—says early investor in Amazon and Tesla  FortuneJensen Huang's Nvidia could be worth more than current S&P 500 index value in ten years: Report  Hindustan TimesNvidia could reach...
6 minutes ago - Amazon Prime Day causes workplace injuries, Senate probe finds  The Washington PostBernie Sanders says Amazon's warehouse workers get injured at an 'outrageous level' during Prime Day season  FortuneWhen is Amazon Prime Day 2024? Dates,...
6 minutes ago - Andreessen Horowitz founders plan to donate to pro-Trump super PAC  CNBCMarc Andreessen, Ben Horowitz Say They Plan to Donate to Trump PAC  The InformationSilicon Valley’s tech titans line up to donate to Donald Trump  Financial...
6 minutes ago - The Trump economy: Slower growth, higher prices and a bigger national debt  Al Jazeera EnglishWorld needs economic stability after a tough few years, but if Trump wins we’re unlikely to get it  The GuardianHow Trumponomics Could Undermine...