pwshub.com

Finance expert says Man United would have breached PSR last season

A football finance expert believes Manchester United were close to breaching the Premier League's Profit and Sustainability Rules (PSR) last season, but managed to comply with the top-flight's restrictions thanks to two 'exceptional allowances.'

Last season, Everton were sanctioned twice by the Premier League for falling foul of their financial restrictions, with the Toffees being deducted a total of eight points for two separate charges after falling foul of the rules. Nottingham Forest were also handed a four-point fine for admitting a breach of the league's rules.

PSR has caused chaos around the English top-flight, with teams having to think cleverly on how to comply with the rules.

In effect, the regulations require clubs to report only a certain amount of losses across a three-year period, up to June 30. Clubs are not able to lose more than £105million over a three-year period - which equates to £35m each year.

Man United, meanwhile, have undergone a period of change in the last 12 months. The arrival of new minority owner Sir Jim Ratcliffe and INEOS has seen the British billionaire shake things up at Old Trafford, from board level right down to matchday staff.

A football finance expert believes that Man United could have fallen foul of the Premier League's financial rules last season

According to the expert, Erik ten Hag's side managed to avoid any breaches thanks to two 'exceptional allowances' 

Man United have undergone a period of change following INEOS' £1.3bn investment into the club

Following INEOS' £1.3billion investment in the club, United have been delving into the transfer market, having signed Leny Yoro and Joshua Zirkzee already this summer, with the Red Devils paying almost £86m for the pair.

United are also undergoing a £50m training ground refurbishment and there has been much talk that the club could build a new 100,000-seat stadium.

But according to football finance expert Stefan Borson, United came close to breaching PSR last season.

'United is very interesting because we do have quite a lot of information about United because of their quarterly report in the US and so we know that they’ve told us that the end of year results will have a £660million top line and about £140m EBITDA,' Borson told talkSPORT.

'It also tells us certain things about their costs. [The] bottom line is when you drag that down on the three-year assessment, United would have failed PSR for the season for the season just gone, save for two things.'

'One, they were given, it appears an exceptional allowance of £40m for Covid in 2022, which no other club had.

'The most any other club had was about £1m in that year. We don't know how they got it.

'On top of that it seems they’ve been given allowance for around £35m of exceptional costs relating to the share sale to (INEOS CEO Sir Jim) Ratcliffe which to be honest, the Glazers should have paid that themselves anyway given they were the main beneficiary.'

United have also been active in the transfer market with Joshua Zirkzee becoming their first signing of the summer window

The Red Devils have also completed the £52m signing of highly-rated Lille defender Leny Yoro, 18

'But we know from the numbers that it was £35m and the only way in which they can make the 23/24 PSR numbers and this is not just my view but the view of multiple people who run the numbers, is by having these allowances.'

Questions have been raised over United's £40m COVID allowance in recent days, with another football finance expert Kieran Maguire taking to X to explain the fund.

Having investigated the matter, he explained on X: 'I’ve been asked by a few people to investigate £40m COVID allowance that Man Utd have in 21/22 accounts.

'Have spoken to senior sources at Club & elsewhere. The reasons are 1) Cancellation of Summer 2021 tour; 2) Bad debts caused by commercial partner insolvency; 3) Club unable to fulfil sponsorship partner obligations in summer 2021; and 4) Broadcaster rebates PL & UEFA.

'Because #MUFC are listed in New York has to disclose more information than other clubs, many of whom have COVID claims but not shown in accounts Conclusion: No corruption from PL.'

There are several other clubs around the league who are still under scrutiny from PSR, including Leicester.

Kieran Maguire has also been investigating Man United's £40m Covid allowance and has explained why the sum was given to the Red Devils 

United have returned from their pre-season tour of the United States this week ahead of their FA Community Shield clash against rivals Man City

The main obstacle to redevelopment over the years has been the rail track behind the Sir Bobby Charlton Stand

The Foxes could face sanctions next season after they were charged in March for falling foul of the rules in relation to the 2022-23 season, where they suffered relegation to the Championship.

Newcastle are another side who have been working to avoid a financial sanction and are looking to raise more capital to ensure they meet the requirements of the regulations.

Man City, meanwhile, are currently locked in a legal battle with the Premier League over the 115 alleged charges of breaching the English top-flight's financial rules.

While no specific date for the highly-anticipated trial to take place, an initial hearing could take place in November and last up to six weeks.

Meanwhile, clubs have also voted in favour of replacing PSR from the 2025-26 season and will instead implement squad cost control regulations. These will limit clubs to spending 85 per cent of their total revenue on wages, transfers and agent fees.

Source: dailymail.co.uk

Related stories
2 weeks ago - ISAAN KHAN: The Gunners are in a very strong financial position, at a time rivals are struggling to navigate the Premier League 's Profit and Sustainability Rules.
3 weeks ago - The conversation where Enzo Maresca told Raheem Sterling he was not part of his plans should have taken place long before the first game of the season.
1 month ago - Welcome to the world of the football kit launch in 2024. The days of Tony Adams or Alan Shearer posing, military-style, in their new club shirts belong to another era.
5 days ago - The perennial champions are defending 115 separate alleged breaches of financial rules spanning nine years from 2009 and the sternest punishment if found guilty is relegation.
6 days ago - Top-flight clubs are allowed to lose up to 105m over a three-year period under Profit and Sustainability Rules. But United's figures took them well above that mark with a total in excess of £250m.
Other stories
20 minutes ago - CHRIS WHEELER: Hojlund and Mount have returned to training this week after recovering from hamstring problems, and could be in contention for Saturday's trip to Crystal Palace.
20 minutes ago - SAMI MOKBEL: Manchester City midfielder Rodri broke ranks this week to indicate players were taking matters into their own hands and that players are 'close' to striking.
21 minutes ago - Supporters have been posting sympathetic messages in response after the forward deleted his Instagram account following a slew of anonymous abuse.
21 minutes ago - It seems Borussia Dortmund have a knack for acquiring English youngsters and turning them into world-class players.
21 minutes ago - The clip, taken after they conceded a last-minute equaliser to draw 2-2 at Sint-Truiden in October 2021, sees the manager show the team 'one f***ing side of [him] that [they] haven't f***ing seen'.