pwshub.com

Man United's latest Old Trafford plan

Gareth Edwards hit the nail on the head when he spoke to my colleague Riath Al-Samarrai in February at Cardiff Arms Park, the scene of his iconic try for the Barbarians against the All Blacks in 1973.

'I went over in the corner and I'm not sure what's there now — it might be a toilet,' Edwards said in the interview.

It was meant in jest but the point is a serious one. When you bulldoze a stadium, you bury a piece of history too. The Arms Park was redeveloped in the 80s and Edwards can no longer locate the exact point where he grounded the greatest try ever scored.

The pitch may only have moved a few metres here or there, but the exact co-ordinates have been lost; locations distorted, memories diluted.

That, essentially, was the dilemma facing Manchester United when they looked at a brand new £2billion stadium. For all the benefits of a state-of-the-art arena built within the broader footprint of Old Trafford, there was no getting away from the fact that the some of the club's heritage would disappear beneath the rubble.

Man United are looking at building a new £2bn stadium - but Old Trafford could be preserved 

Yes, you can relocate statues and the monuments to Munich, but it would never be quite the same for many fans. They couldn't bear to see Old Trafford disappear completely from the Manchester skyline, even if it paved the way for a new stadium that would allow United to protect their status as one of the biggest clubs in the world.

United fans are not alone in that sense, of course. Survey the football landscape and so many great English football grounds have been lost in the name of progress. Every supporter of every club will have their own view on whether it was worth it.

But what United are now proposing is quite unique in English football: build a new stadium next door to Old Trafford but keep the essence of the old one for posterity.

Keep the Munich clock and tunnel where they are. Keep the statues to Sir Matt Busby, Sir Alex Ferguson, Jimmy Murphy, Sir Bobby Charlton, Denis Law and George Best on the spot where they were erected. Keep the memories intact.

The stadium would me modified but it has always been a work in progress anyway. When it opened in 1910, Old Trafford's capacity was around 80,000. By the 80s that had dropped to 60,000 and then 44,000 when it became all-seater after the Hillsborough Disaster. It went up again when the current Sir Alex Ferguson Stand was expanded for Euro 96.

If United don't have the finance to build a new stadium, Old Trafford will be redeveloped at a cost of roughly £1billion. So change is coming either way.

But the preference is clearly to create a 100,000-capacity Wembley of the North, and it's a plan that ensures the best of both worlds: a new stadium that will allow United to catch up their rivals while preserving the heritage of the club.

Old Trafford will remain as a monument to more than a hundred years of history. Fans can still look upon the pitch where their heroes of yesteryear played. And what better stage for the youth academy than the home of the Busby Babes? In the short term, it means United can stay and play at Old Trafford rather than relocating elsewhere.

Keeping Old Trafford will allow the club to retain the iconic trinity statue outside the stadium

There will be debates about finance, both private and public, for a club owned by billionaires. Naming rights will be discussed. Applications for government funding and council planning. But that's for another day.

United have a vision that embraces the future and protects the past. If it's feasible, Old Trafford will rise again, greater than ever.

Source: dailymail.co.uk

Related stories
1 month ago - CHRIS WHEELER: Sir Dave Brailsford's marginal gains approach had played a part in United designing a meticulous plan for the players which included wearing tailored compression garments.
1 week ago - The Sky Sports pundits sat side by side on the gantry at Old Trafford on Sunday during commentary duties, with Carragher's former Reds side coming out on top against their fiercest rivals, winning 3-0.
1 month ago - Confidential understands that a meeting was held on Monday with United's top brass to discuss strategy for the remainder of the window, with a midfielder a priority focus to strengthen the side.
1 week ago - Pressure has increased on the Dutchman on the back of his side's 3-0 defeat by Liverpool last Sunday, with the Red Devils losing two of their first three matches of the Premier League season.
1 month ago - This summer's transfer window has already been a busy one. Here are the new WAGs we can expect to see in the stands throughout the 2024-24 Premier League season.
Other stories
12 minutes ago - ISAAN KHAN IN BERGAMO: Ahead of their opening match against Atalanta tonight, Mikel Arteta's side are no longer newcomers on this stage.
13 minutes ago - The video is mesmerising. Full of lively music, twinkling sounds and graphics that revolve as quickly as a fruit machine, UEFA pulled no punches to launch what they are calling 'the new beginning.'
1 hour ago - An embarrassing late blunder for a former Premier League stopper gifted Paris St Germain a 1-0 home victory over Champions League debutants Girona on Wednesday night.
1 hour ago - The legendary rock and roll band recently announced the group - led by City fanatic brothers Liam and Noel Gallagher - are getting back together and the club have got in on the action.
1 hour ago - Haaland was kept quiet on a night in which he missed out on his 100th goal for the club but he was all smiles during an animated chat with Acerbi after the final whistle.